I think it's safe to say that many of us are re-examining what it means to be a hero in light of our current world-wide crisis. There are so many everyday heroes working the front lines and risking exposure on a daily basis (doctors, nurses, grocery store workers); sometimes it even feels like a heroic act to support 3 kids through digital learning while my husband and I run our own classes from home. This is actually a topic I've thought about a lot in recent years, especially when I was in active breast cancer treatment. I can't tell you how many times I heard, "You're so brave," simply because they saw me out and about with a bald head. This always gave me pause. I didn't feel brave. I felt like I was forced to deal with something. It's not like I chose to run into a burning building and save the lives of a litter of puppies. No, my body over-produced cells for a period of time and I had to go through treatment to save myself. And really I didn't save myself, my team of doctors and nurses saved me. Which brings me back to the original point that these are the true heroes of the day. As such, I want to share my Writing Heroes lesson plan to do my very small part to help make life easier for the educators and parents teaching writing from home right now.
I've taught a variation of this lesson for probably ten+ years. When I first got involved with the writing project we had a Young Authors Institute at San Jose State and I taught a week of Hero Writing to 4th-7th graders (note that we still offer this program, though it's now called Writing Workshop). Now keep in mind, when we teach our summer programs we have the same group of students for HOURS every day and we are focused only on teaching writing. You know we have to keep things interesting! I usually pair these activities with a study of excerpts of Percy Jackson & The Olympians that I read aloud to students (truth: I remembered I had this lesson sequence because I recently purchased the box set of this book series for my own 9 and 10 year old kiddos - they're a bit young for the series but they listen and read along with audible and they are LOVING it so far). This is a parred down version of this unit in which I've selected some of my favorite activities. I've kept these lessons around 30-40 minutes apiece.
Day 1: What Makes a Hero?
I always begin this lesson sequence by asking students, "What makes a hero?" In fact, I often start units by posing an essential question to students BEFORE we have studied anything. I like to get them thinking about the questions we will be exploring on their own first because you know they all come into our classrooms with oceans of ideas!
ACTIVITY 1: What Makes A Hero? Quickwrite
Students will write for 5 minutes on the essential question, what makes a hero? In a traditional classroom I always have students pair or group share their ideas before we move into a whole class discussion. In a digital classroom I would have students write on the idea and either ask that each student comment on the ideas of 1-2 classmates or if you are using zoom or google hangouts you could try for a class discussion whole group. That said, I would limit the class discussion to 5-10 minutes in order to fit the rest of the lesson into the 30-40 minute time frame.
ACTIVITY 2 : Heroic Acts Ranking Sheet
After students have had a chance to think about the qualities of a hero on their own, I give them a Heroic Acts Ranking Sheet. This handout has 10 heroic acts listed and I ask students to rank the acts from most to least heroic. This is a very difficult task designed to get them thinking about the different ways people can behave heroically. We always follow this activity with another class discussion. Typically students will argue that if an act is at all self-serving it is less heroic than the acts that involve personal sacrifice (for instance, they will often argue that it is less heroic to save your own child than to save a stranger...and that it is less heroic if someone is doing their job in the process of being a hero - but is it, though?). Again, this classroom discussion would need to be modified for digital learning. Perhaps you could have students pick their top 1-3 heroic acts and write a couple of sentences defending their selections, which would be a quick tie in to argumentative writing. That said, this is a great activity for whole class discussion so if you can zoom it go for it! Click below to download the Heroic Acts Ranking Sheet.
Day 2: Build A Half A Hero
Once we have talked about what makes a hero in a real life context I move this into a discussion of heroes in stories. First, I define hero as being an alternate term for protagonist, or character from whose perspective a story is told. In a traditional classroom I will do this as a call back exercise: "When I say hero, you say protagonist. Hero... Protagonist! Hero...Protagonist! Protagonist...Hero!" I'm not sure how to modify this for a digital classroom but I invite you to give it a try and share how it went in the comments below! Next, I tell students that we are going to begin to write heroes into existence through a partner activity I call Build A Half A Hero.
ACTIVITY 1: Build A Half A Hero Partner Writing
I've done this activity online with students in Once Upon A Novel, a class that I teach in the summers for the writing project, so I know it works digitally! I assign students a partner and give each partner different prompts so that they are each creating a half of a hero. They then put their notes together to form one whole hero, who often has complex (and sometimes contradictory) traits. Oh what it is to be human! Or not, sometimes one partner will decide that the hero lives on another planet and their partner has to find a way to work that surprise into their own writing. Here are the prompts for this exercise:
Day 3: Heroes vs. Villains
How can you talk about heroes without talking about villains? Especially when villains are SO MUCH FUN to write! I begin this day by asking students what a villain is. This is typically a quick write into a quick class discussion before I completely debunk most of their notions of good and evil. I say debunk because most teachers don't understand villains in the same way that writers do. Writers know that villains do not have to be bad. In fact, they can be better people than your hero. They simply have to be in competition with your hero over something. Here is how basic conflict works in a story.
THE HERO WANTS SOMETHING. THE VILLAIN ALSO WANTS SOMETHING. CONFLICT: For one to win...the other must lose!
Sometimes the hero and villain want the same thing (the same scholarship, the same romantic interest, the same diamond sword designed that makes people it stabs invincible). Other times, they want opposing things (the hero wants peace and the villain wants world domination, the hero wants freedom and the villain wants to control the hero). Either way, only one character can get what they want. Their respective journeys to go after what they want will fuel the plot of the story (sometimes the hero is taking action to get their desire, other times they are reacting to the antagonist's attempts to attain their desire).
Now that we've established the differences between a hero and a villain it's time to write! First, though, I ask students to identify something their hero wants more than anything else in the world. Next, I ask them to put an antagonist force in the way of this desire (in a full length unit we go into the different types of antagonistic forces because your villain doesn't actually have to be human).
ACTIVITY 1: WRITE WHAT YOUR HERO WANTS
What does your hero want? Write a scene describing your hero holding that thing in his or her hand. If it is a person the hero wants, write the hero holding that person's hand. If it is a virtue (like freedom), write the hero holding an object that represents that virtue in his or her hand.
Day 4: 3-2-1 Writing
By this point in the week we know significantly more about what it means to be a hero than we did at the start of the week so we are ready to kick our writing into high gear. We've talked a bit about what we're going to write (the conflict between the hero and villain), now we begin to explore how we're going to write it. For this activity I have students write three variations of the same scene. I call this 3-2-1 writing. Each of these scenes is going to center around an essential conflict between the hero and the villain.
THE PROMPT: Write a scene in which your hero is locked in a ferocious battle with the villain in an attempt to get that thing that (s)he wants more than anything else in the world. Give this battle to the villain (in other words let him be victorious). It's ok! We all know that your hero will win the whole thing, so let's knock our protagonists around a bit.
3 Write the first draft of this scene in third person (the shortest way to explain this to students is to say that you are going to write the scene so that all of the characters are referred to by name or third person pronouns like he/him)
2 Write another draft of the same scene so that the whole thing unfolds as dialogue between two people (the hero and the villain).
1 Re-write the scene so that it is told in first person from the hero's perspective. In this draft the hero will use the personal pronoun "I" to convey his or her version of events. As an added bonus you can try to rewrite the scene for a 4th time from the Villain's perspective. What fun! Who knows, they may end up being the true hero of the story.
Day 5: Writing In Scene
Now that we've covered essential elements of what it means to be a hero, it's time for students to write in scene so that action unfolds in real time. Now, how to write in scene could (and should) be a unit in and of itself but I would consider this a pre-assessment from which to design curriculum. At this point I would have students write for a solid block of time (20-30 minutes). Use the prompt below to write for that period.
PROMPT: WRITE YOUR HERO WINNING
Your last pieces of writing featured your hero losing (3 different times!). Now it's your hero's turn! Write your hero locked in another vicious battle with the villain. Only this time, let your hero be victorious! Go forth and have fun!